Acer Aspire One review – 10 months later
Note about this “review”: I started writing this review several months ago, but since it’s a rather boring thing to write I never finished it. So please excuse the rambling.
Second note: This is a review of the Linux version, not the Windows one. A lot of my complaints will not exist on the Windows version.
…
My Acer Aspire One – after 10 months of usage
I bought my aspire one sometime in summer/autumn 2008.
I’ve used it mostly for programming, writing and web browsing.
Looks
Most important first. It looks very nice in my humble opinion. I got the shiny blue version.
Speed
The Firefox 2 web browser slows when initially loading Google Docs, and also freezes for a second or two when saving a large document. Also freezes up when loading a video on the BBC news website, but I guess that is more the fault of the BBC’s resource hogging player, as YouTube works fine. The fan kicks in when browsing more intense sites like YouTube mind. But in general it is still perfectly usable.
Battery
Supplied battery is rubbish. Lasts about 2 hours on low power settings. If you want serious mobility like me you will have to shell out on the bigger battery, which cost me about £70.
The bigger battery has at least 5 hours of life, and if you carry the smaller battery along with you you have some very respectable hourage going on.
The larger battery does stick out a bit, making the aspire one look not quite as sleek and compact (plus increasing the weight a little). But it’s not too bad. When it is on a desk with the screen opened you don’t really notice.
Linux
I got the Linux version, as it was cheaper. I am however somewhat familiar with Linux. It uses “Linpus” Linux, which is based on some old version of Red Hat/Fedora.
Linux – unified drive
The unification of the expandable memory is nice in theory. Probably for the average user it will be fine. But there are some niggles… one I keep coming up against is that I have a shell script in my home directory set to executable… but somehow this manages to reset itself to non-executable after every boot. A little irritating, but not the end of the world.
Probably an advanced Linux user might want to install their own favourite Linux flavour anyway – the average user won’t be using shell scripts.
Some apps will occasionally ignore the unified drive and only access the original drive…. e.g. /a is the original drive, /b is expansion memory, and /c is the “unified” drive. Sometimes OpenOffice will open to /a instead of /c as it should. Hmmm, I don’t really know how to explain that better.
In summary I think the unified drive, while a nice idea, really fails in practice.
Linux – MP3 playback
Getting the thing to play MP3s was a bitch. After trying many and varied different things, and scouring various repositories I finally managed to get Audacious to play MP3s. Amarok I couldn’t get to play them.
Also, could not get some DIVX videos to play. Tried installing various things for mplayer, xine and co. but gave up eventually. I never really intended to watch video on this so it’s no great loss for me.
So unless you are really tenacious you won’t be listening to MP3s or watching videos on the Linpus Linux Acer One.
Wireless Network
I’ve seen some issues on the forums and complaints about it dropping the connection, but this is not something I’ve experienced.
Using it on my university network, it did not support the required authorisation (some kind of wireless VPN network or something) which required a username and password to log on (as opposed to simple a key for everyone). Took a lot of hunting to get this to work. Finally found some nice tutorial on the aspire one user forums. This required updating network manager. And since that, I have been too afraid to run the automated updates in case it gets rid of these hacks. So maybe there are some updates I am missing, who knows?
This non-support of VPNs and other advanced authentication methods is very unfortunate. Support is lacking only because the preinstalled network manager is an outdated version. This is something they could easily remedy (and maybe they have in updates, but I really do not want to risk breaking my network connection to find out).
other stuff
Occasionally (maybe 5 times in the time I’ve owned it) it’s completely frozen up. Nothing to do but restart. 2 of those times I’ve lost stuff I’ve been writing. This should not happen. In this day and age, even the notorious Windows never freezes up completely. Maybe it is the fault of the old version of red hat linux. You never expect a complete system freeze when working in a text editor. Anyway. This is bad, but fortunately happens so rarely that it is not a major concern. Normal behaviour is to save regularly when working on an important document anyway…
Sometimes the wireless icon in the task bar fails to appear on system start. Maybe this is the fault of me upgrading the NetworkManager. Who knows. Generally it will appear on the next reboot.
OVERALL
Overall there are a lot of niggles. But appearance and keyboard are very good. I have a suspicion that most of these niggles are the fault of an old and badly configured version of Linux and might not be present in the Windows version.
Reading all the above, I realise this is more of a list of complaints than a review. There are good points, but you can read other reviews to find them out :)
I’m happy with my Acer One. It is a rather pretty little thing.


